Why your New Year's resolutions will fail — and how to plan a strategic reset instead

I discovered that a fresh start is a process. A fresh start is a journey—a journey that requires a plan.

—- Vivian Jokotade

We've all been there. The January 1st rush. Followed by the February 1st crash.

It's the second week of December, and if you're like most people, you're already thinking about January 1st. Maybe you're planning to finally increase your fitness, build new communication patterns, or break a habit that's been holding you back.

You can feel it: that surge of possibility, the clean slate, the promise that this time will be different.

Here's what the research tells us: it probably won't be.

Approximately 80% of New Year's resolutions are abandoned by February 1st, and about 25% don't even make it past the first two weeks. If those numbers feel personal, you're not alone.

The Problem with Resolutions

The very word "resolution" sets us up for failure. A resolution implies a firm decision, a once-and-for-all commitment. It's binary: you either keep your resolution or you break it.

Behaviorally, a resolution is what psychologist Peter Gollwitzer calls a goal intention—a declaration of a desired outcome without a mechanism for achieving it. Research shows that goal intentions alone account for only 20-30% of the variance in actual behavior change.

A resolution is essentially a stated wish without a sustainable system.

What we actually need isn't another resolution. We need a reset.

A reset acknowledges that change is iterative, not instantaneous. It builds in the expectation of adjustment, learning, and course-correction. While a resolution says "I will never eat sugar again," a reset says "I'm redesigning my relationship with food, and I'll learn as I go."

Behavioral scientist Katy Milkman's research on the fresh start effect explains why gym memberships spike in January. Temporal landmarks like New Year's Day create a psychological separation between your "past self" and your "future self," which boosts motivation. But here's the problem: fresh starts boost the desire and excitement to change without improving your capacity (skills, resources, and systems) to change.

Many of us treat a resolution like a magic moment, when what we need is a reset with a structured renewal process that supports how we grow, change and learn.

Four Critical Breaking Points

After analyzing decades of behavioral research, four patterns emerge as the primary saboteurs of even our best resolution-worthy intentions.

1. First, we get trapped in cycles of false hope. We repeat the same goals with the same strategies. But we don't fail because we can't do it—we fail because we think it will be faster and easier than it actually is. A reset acknowledges past data and adjusts accordingly.

2. Second, we treat our journey as pass/fail. Resolutions typically have no "Plan B" clarified. They rely on Action Planning (when and where you'll act) without Coping Planning (what you'll do when obstacles arise). A reset builds in strategies for getting back on track.

3. Third, we're often chasing the wrong goals. Many resolutions are not rooted in authentic values but in societal pressure or even guilt. This creates "cognitive friction"—where the brain is constantly inhibiting the desire not to do the behavior. An authentic reset starts with values alignment and connects goals to your identity.

4. Fourth, our environment sabotages our best intentions. Your environment has invisible defaults, and resolutions try to fight these through willpower. A reset changes the defaults in strategic ways.

Let's take a closer look at the research basis for each breaking point.

Breaking Point #1: The False Hope Loop

Psychologists Janet Polivy and C. Peter Herman identified false hope syndrome, which explains why you might be planning next year’s gym routine — even though you haven't touched your current membership since February.

Here's the cycle:

1. You set an ambitious goal.

2. You fail.

3. But instead of thinking "Maybe this goal was unrealistic," you tell yourself "I just didn't try hard enough." (This feels better because your effort seems controllable).

So you set a resolve with the same goal and same strategy, but energized with renewed determination.

The sobering reality check: Polivy & Herman's research research shows people often repeat the same self-change attempts year after year, cycling between optimism and relapse.

False Hope Syndrome thrives on unrealistic expectations:

1. We overestimate speed: Initial progress tricks us into thinking we can maintain that pace indefinitely.

2. We underestimate difficulty: We forget about stress, environmental triggers, and our body's resistance to change.

3. We believe one change will fix everything: That losing weight will fix your marriage, or waking up at 5 AM will make you successful in your business. When these sweeping transformations don't materialize, motivation collapses.

A resolution says "try harder."

A reset says "try differently, and expect it to take longer or be more challenging than you think."

Breaking Point #2: The Pass/Fail Trap

Let's say you've made it to late January. You're doing well—eating healthy, hitting the gym, staying consistent. Then one night, stressed from work, you eat a cookie.

In that moment, your brain faces a choice. You could think, "That's fine, one cookie doesn't change anything," and move on. Or you could think, "Well, I've already ruined the day. Might as well eat the whole box."

If you choose the latter, you've experienced what Polivy and Herman call counter-regulatory behavior. One small slip feels like total collapse, so we give ourselves permission to fully indulge.

The guilt and shame after that first cookie actually depletes willpower, making us more likely to keep eating. Research on restrained eating shows the more rigid your boundaries, the more explosive the reaction when one gets crossed.

Research by Falko Sniehotta distinguishes between action planning (when and where you'll act) and coping planning (anticipating barriers). Action planning is good for starting but coping planning predicts long-term maintenance. When you think in terms of resets, a lapse isn't failure—it's data, feedback, an opportunity to recalibrate.

The people who succeed aren't the ones who never slip. They're the ones who slip and yet don't spiral.

A resolution has Plan A but no Plan B.

A reset builds in contingency plans from the beginning.

Breaking Point #3: The Authenticity Gap

Without understanding your deeper "why," even well-designed resolutions crumble. This is why resets must start with values clarification, not just behavior change.

Self-determination theory, developed by psychologists Edward Deci and Richard Ryan, makes a critical distinction:

• Intrinsic motivation: "I exercise because I love feeling strong."

• Extrinsic motivation: "I must exercise because society says I should look a certain way."

Research by Sheldon & Elliot shows that self-concordant goals (goals aligned with one’s own values and interests rather than external pressure) lead to higher persistence and greater well-being. Obligation-based goals feel harder because they produce mental friction- your mind keeps fighting the resistance rather than moving you forward. This is exhausting.

Resolutions demand action immediately. A reset honors the preparation phase, where you clarify your deeper values, assess the barriers, and build coping strategies before you start.

The solution isn't just identifying what you want to change—it's understanding why it matters to you at a core level. When your goal connects to your authentic values, the pursuit generates energy. You're not fighting yourself; you're expressing yourself.

A resolution enforces an external rule.

A reset aligns the goal with your identity and your values.

Breaking Point #4: The Environment Effect

We often think of goal pursuit as primarily an internal battle. But research tells a different story: your environment is often more powerful than your intentions. A proper reset redesigns the environment, not just your willpower.

Behavior follows the path of least resistance. Choice architecture research shows that even tiny nudges in your environment can make the ‘right’ choice feel easier, helping you stick to better habits.

For example, research findings show that women who kept soda on their kitchen counters weighed up to 26 pounds more than those who didn't, purely due to the visual cue. Similar research shows that simply placing fruit prominently in school cafeterias significantly increased consumption.

Your environment has invisible defaults, which are the ‘automatic’ setting it reverts to when you're not thinking. Design with these automatic tendencies in mind:

1. Make it obvious: Put your running shoes by the door.

2. Make it invisible: Delete the apps that drain your time.

3. Make it difficult: Put your credit card in a drawer.

4. Make it easy: Meal prep on Sunday so healthy eating requires no decisions.

A resolution says "I will rely on my discipline."

A reset says "I will design conditions that make good choices automatic.”

A fresh start isn't a new place, it's a new mindset.

— Gary John Bishop

---

How to Design a Strategic, Science-Based Reset

Successful resets share three core elements that correspond to the breaking points we've explored:

1. Clarify a positive future vision (aligned with your values). Research by Richard Boyatzis shows that having a positive vision that integrates your authentic values is crucial—it activates the brain's reward centers and generates the energy needed for sustained change. This is your positive emotional attractor, the compelling future that pulls you forward.

2. At the same time you need to assess and design for the realistic barriers as you work towards your positive vision - a tension known as mental contrasting. Psychologist Gabrielle Oettingen's research reveals the optimal strategy is to hold both your desired future and the realistic barriers in your mind simultaneously. This creates what Oettingen calls a binding commitment—your brain recognizes the obstacle as something standing between you and what you want, which energizes you to overcome it.

3. Refine your ‘coping planning’ skills. Obstacle planning is essential for long-term sustainability. When you anticipate the specific barriers you'll face and create contingency plans in advance, you're not resolving for a perfect journey—you're designing a resilient one. The obstacle isn't a failure of your resolve; it's an expected part of the process you've already planned for.

The people who succeed at change aren't the ones with the most willpower or the strongest resolutions. They're the ones who understand their brain's limitations and design strategic resets to support the change they want to see.

You don't need another resolution. You need a reset.

---

6 Coaching Questions for a Strategic Reset

1. What does the most compelling version of my future look like—the one that genuinely excites me?
2. What is a realistic assessment of my challenges and opportunities? What realities have I consistently underestimated in past attempts?
3. What specific barriers have stopped me before, and what new obstacles am I likely to face this time?
4. When I slip up, what's my plan for getting back on track?
5. If I could only change one thing about my environment to support this goal, what would it be?
6. What's the version of this goal that's so small it feels almost embarrassing?

---

Get the Complete Toolkit to Inspire Growth & Change

Get my free 60-page ebook featuring my 8-step process for growth and 80 powerful questions for coaching or reflection - designed for leaders, coaches, & personal growth enthusiasts.
​
You'll also join 2,000+ professionals who receive The Coaching Mindset, my newsletter for practical tips to inspire intentional growth and tools to take a coach approach.